The commerce struggle between the US and Canada—extra precisely between the American authorities and the Canadian authorities(s)—helps illustrate the opposition between two regimes: free commerce between people or non-public organizations, which creates mutual features and favors peaceable relations; commerce between governments or directed by them, that’s, mercantilism, which generates conflicts and hatred.
After US President Donald Trump had introduced 10% tariffs on imports of Canadian “power merchandise” and 25% import tariffs on all different items, the federal authorities of Canada introduced retaliatory tariffs on American exports. The premier of the province of Ontario, Doug Ford, simply introduced a provincial tax of 25% on Ontarian exports of electrical energy to New York, Michigan, and Minnesota. He declared (“Ontario Hits Energy Exports to US With 25% Surcharge as Commerce Warfare Accelerates,” Monetary Instances, March 10, 2020):
If needed, if the US escalates, I can’t hesitate to close the electrical energy off utterly.”
He had beforehand stated (“Canada to Reduce Off Electrical energy to US States: ‘Have to Really feel the Ache,’” Newsweek, March 4, 2025):
In the event that they wish to attempt to annihilate Ontario, I’ll do all the things—together with minimize off their power with a smile on my face, and I’m encouraging each different province to do the identical.
They depend on our power. They should really feel the ache.
People and their non-public events commerce along with a smile on their faces. Governments intervene in commerce and impose ache with a smile on their collective face, if we might use that analogy. The truth that the Ontario Authorities owns or straight controls a big a part of the manufacturing and distribution of electrical energy in Ontario (“our power”), as do to a lesser extent the governments of the importing US states, doesn’t assist depoliticize the market. Topic to weak constitutional constraints, governments can anyway impose tariffs, taxes, and prohibitions on whom they determine, and the consequence isn’t common love.
That Mr. Ford is himself a conservative with a populist streak, who as soon as expressed his help for Mr. Trump, ought to remind us to watch out for the “will of the individuals.”
In a latest publish, I quoted Henry Adams, who wrote that
politics, as a apply, no matter its professions, has all the time been the systematic organisation of hatreds.
From an ethical viewpoint versus a slim financial viewpoint, which ruler begins the battle isn’t irrelevant.
******************************
Two mercantilist kings
